Editorial Quality Check
Pre-acceptance manuscript review tool
→ Desk Review Tool
Internal Use Only
Tool updated — now assesses three dimensions only: Novelty & Contribution, Methodology & Claim Discipline, and Clarity & Writing. Literature Coverage and Analysis & Interpretation have been removed as they could not be assessed reliably from extracted text alone.

This tool performs an AI-assisted quality assessment of manuscripts at the pre-acceptance stage. The output is an advisory summary only — it does not constitute a recommendation. All final decisions rest with the handling editor.

Please ensure you select the correct article type before running. The assessment criteria differ significantly between Research Articles, Review Articles, and Perspectives.
Analysing manuscript — this may take 20–40 seconds for a full paper…

AI Advisory Summary —
Copied to clipboard